Authors and Cyber-bullying

23057698_sFor some time, I’ve heard and seen authors complaining on my various writing e-mail loops about negative reviews being handed out at the Amazondotcom site. It appears this has become even more of a problem over time. The other day, in walks an e-mail to my inbox, asking me to sign a Petition at Changedotorg in an attempt to force the online retail giant to – at the least – enforce its own guidelines. Editor Todd Barselow is the person behind this appeal, seemingly feed up with Amazon, the bullying, and harassment of all authors. In my research, I read some not so friendly comments with regard to Mr. Barselow, and his campaign, but that is not what this post will be about. Whatever bones there are to pick, dislikes, or what have you, with and about Mr. Barselow I’ll leave to the discontented.

For those of you who do not know, there had also been a war of sorts going on with regard to bad reviews and bashing taking place over at the Goodreads site. If you take a spin by Changedotorg you will find a Petition there as well, with a request for signatures. In a look at this problem I would, of course, like to remain unbiased, but as you can imagine as a writer I have a very strong sentiment with regard to this issue, which would make neutrality very difficult. In searching, it doesn’t appear that either Jeff Bezos, Founder and CEO, or Jon P. Fine, Director of Amazon has ever spent hours, days, weeks, months, or years pouring their blood, sweat and tears – bearing down through labor pains, giving birth to a work that’s then considered your baby. Yes, Mr. Bezos, as Founder, did suffer some type of adversity trying to get the business up and running; maybe. That being said, it should all make him even more sensitive to this new plight of the writer. I would hate to label it by saying, “He has his, why should he care” – but the facts are leaning in that direction. Goodreads, however, has made modifications to their user terms to prevent author bullying.

I think as a writer we may all have a story or two involving what is clearly – jealousy. But, you know, I’ve heard it said that if you’re not willing to put in the time, then one cannot complain, grumble, or criticize another’s success. I think, in this age of cyber-bullying, tighter rules must be set in place to protect us writers from the public-at-large. I mean, it’s bad enough to get a bad review from a professional reviewer, am I right? Most of us, the ones who have been in the business for any time, have developed a crusty exterior; we know what to take in as constructive and what to simply let go. But, how could someone develop a platform such as Amazon or Goodreads and not build that into the system – rules that do not allow any and everyone to leave whatever disparaging comment they like. Or, at least, put a team in place to enforce the codes. I may be coming up the rear with this story as it has been some time since this all began, but I too wanted to weigh in, and express my opinion.

If you talk to any writer they will most likely tell you, it is something they’ve done since childhood. Most of us have read, studied, took classes, joined organizations, went to meetings and spent an innumerable amount of hours in an attempt to perfect the craft. How then, can you produce a work – have it published, and then, get a portion of your backside chewed away by mere jealousy, or because someone has nothing better to do than upset a person’s life work. I do believe the simple remedy is – the bully has to turn the tide. Put themselves in the writer’s shoes. I believe our world is spinning faster and faster toward its end, which has ramped up many, many immoral and wicked acts. Even something as stupid as your twitter and/or facebook accounts getting hacked continually. I think we’ve moved way beyond breaking out the ruler and whacking someone on the knuckles. What do you think?

Information Goodreads, & STGRB (Stop The Goodreads Bullies)

Image courtesy


Great Authors – Offensive Writers

Everyone in this writing game is aware that to write well, one must also read; a lot.  I myself, have always been a voracious reader, and I’ve mentioned this on more than one occasion here on my blog.  Now, in that same vein I must ask, why do we like books?  There are a number of reasons. They take us to far away places, increases our knowledge, and helps us escape the everyday life, just to name a few.  With that being said, many of us desire to make our way down the list of greats that have come and gone before us: William Faulkner, F. Scott Fitzgerald, John Steinbeck.  And, it doesn’t matter what nationality the reader is, we all want a peek into the mind of a celebrated author.  I have always been one in love with the mainstream novel.  I haven’t really given much thought to what separates us as readers – I mean, what makes me love conventional, while someone else likes fantasy or historical? But, then, that is a topic for another day.

My all time favorite novelists through the years have been Agatha Christie, Sidney Sheldon and Stephen King. However, this does not mean I haven’t read other works over time.  To assist in making my point, I’d like you to keep in mind those I’ve listed are later day authors.  What do I mean?  I mean they were born into a somewhat changed world.  Let me put it this way – all nationalities would read their books.  As they developed each manuscript, somewhere in the back of their minds they were even attempting to reach that wide demographic, I’m certain.  Since we’ve moved out of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, and for that matter even the twentieth century, I don’t think there is one race of people living in a civilized society who does not enjoy reading.  I will even go a bit further to say, somewhere in a little village on the most remote part of the globe is someone who has learned to use a computer, and who is wishing to order a book from Amazon.

But what happens when someone like myself or any other person of color is working their way through a list of the great novels, and comes across something ugly or offensive. Now, here I’d like to remind you of the later day writers.  In attempting to broaden my horizon, do I overlook that offense, knowing it had been written in another time.  I can hear you asking what offensive thing lead me to this post.  I, as a person of integrity, cannot reveal that, and live with myself.  I must add, it took me a couple, three or four chapters before this particular piece grabbed my interest.  But, after that, I began to enjoy the story.  Until, out of nowhere – that word, the revolting, distasteful one that we all know, showed up, and let me just say I won’t dare repeat it here.  Mind you, this is the only time it’s mentioned in the entire book, which really made the old gray cells start sparking.  I mean, it hit me like I can imagine a drive-by might produce anxiety (putting it mildly).

My husband says I’m making a big deal out of nothing, because I know this came from a different time.  So, maybe this is my irascibility rearing its unattractive head again.  But, you see, I had this dilemma causing a battle in my mind.  Did I wish to continue reading, because I only had about forty pages to the end of the book?  Did I sit and stew over it or did I simply pull out my big girl attitude and finish?  But, regardless of my decision, because the word had been loosed it appeared that all the pages had been emptied, and that ungodly word covered the empty space from front to back.  I understood this had been a character developed by the author, speaking this horrendous word, but I believe it still came from somewhere.  If he/she uses such derogatory language, they may mean it for that particular character, but it came from a place within them.  And believe me when I say, it goes on from there.  If that person carried that within their vocabulary, it most assuredly got tossed around in the home.  Once it’s out in the open, it becomes handed down to the next generation.  And, no matter what that subsequent age group says – get them squeezed in a corner and “bingo,” grandpa comes out.  Now, I know from this there are many, many arguments that can form. But, believe me when I say, until you’ve put on the skin of someone of color, you will never know.  Yes, and I’m not naive – I know there are more books out there like this.  Actually, when I think of it, I can’t say why it struck me the way it did.  It could be my age – who knows, it could have been some kind of rotational pull of the earth.

But, let me ask?  Does that celebrated author – the one who could turn a phrase so poetically, deserve the time and energy I expend in the hopes of expanding my mind, when their thinking had been so obviously narrow-minded?  I don’t know yet, I’m still rolling it around in my mind.  Although, I am always seeking to increase my knowledge – we’re always searching aren’t we?  Life really is too short to waste my time on what I consider a distasteful piece of work.  To sum it all up, I had an overwhelming sense of deception that I had gotten so far in the book, had developed a rapport with the characters, and a fondness for the story to only be snatched away by this evident bigoted author.  So, irascibility or not, I cannot – I will not edify a person, simply because they have been labeled by their peers as great, when this is the work they’ve produced.  Help me out here. Let me know, if you find an author that offends you, do you continue reading?

Photo courtesy of